There is no single answer. Qualified scholars and official Shariah bodies have reached opposite conclusions, and the split is still open. The most recent major ruling goes against crypto. On 10 June 2026 the Darul Ifta of Jamia Darul Uloom Karachi issued a fatwa, signed by Mufti Taqi Usmani and six others. It holds that cryptocurrency, including the stablecoin USDT, is not maal (wealth) under Sharia, and that buying goods with it is impermissible. Other bodies have ruled the other way. In July 2020 the Shariah Advisory Council of Malaysia's Securities Commission said investing in and trading digital currencies and tokens on registered digital asset exchanges is permissible in principle. Whether a particular holding is halal therefore depends on whose ruling you follow, which asset it is, and how you hold or trade it.

The newest development: Karachi's June 2026 fatwa
- 10 June 2026. The Darul Ifta at Jamia Darul Uloom Karachi issued the fatwa. Dawn reported that Mufti Taqi Usmani and six others signed it. According to Salaam Gateway, citing Dawn, it says cryptocurrency "is not considered 'maal' (wealth) in Sharia" and calls it "merely the recording of fictitious numbers in an account". It applies that description "whether in the form of USDT (Tether stablecoin) or other crypto tokens".
- What it was asked about. Profit (Pakistan Today, 10 July 2026) reports that the question concerned books and a digital course paid for in crypto. The fatwa said buying goods with cryptocurrency is impermissible. Mufti Usmani's son, Hassan Usmani, confirmed the fatwa was genuine.
- 11 July 2026. Bilal Bin Saqib, chairman of the Pakistan Virtual Asset Regulatory Authority (PVARA), met Mufti Usmani. Dawn reports that he did not dispute the ruling. He argued that blockchain, stablecoins and tokenised real-world assets are different technologies and should each be assessed on their own, both technically and under Shariah.
- 10 September 2026. Saqib told journalists in Islamabad that Pakistan "is setting up a Shariah Advisory Board" to advise on digital-asset transactions, and that he had "taken Mufti Taqi Usmani into confidence" (ProPakistani).
The fatwa matters because of where it comes from. Darul Uloom Karachi is one of the most influential seminaries in South Asia, and the ruling rests on the threshold question of maal. If crypto is not property, the debate about trading methods never starts.
Rulings and opinions, by date
Against
- Diyanet, Turkey (reported 28 November 2017). Turkey's state Directorate of Religious Affairs said buying and selling virtual currencies is "not compatible with religion at this time". Its reasons were that their value is open to speculation, that they are easily used for illegal activity such as money laundering, and that they fall outside state audit and supervision (Euronews).
- Grand Mufti of Egypt, Shawki Allam (reported 2 January 2018). He ruled bitcoin forbidden. The reasons reported were the lack of central-bank backing, its use in financing terrorism, fraud risk and hard-to-predict prices, harm to a state's control of its currency and tax revenue, and the absence of any central authority (Africanews). Reports differ on whether the fatwa was issued in late December 2017 or early January 2018.
- Majelis Ulama Indonesia (11 November 2021). At its Ijtima Ulama forum, Indonesia's council of scholars ruled that using crypto as currency is haram, citing gharar, harm and conflict with Indonesian payment law. It also ruled that trading crypto as a commodity or digital asset is not valid, because it fails the conditions for a tradable good (sil'ah). Crypto with a clear underlying asset and a proven benefit was excepted.
- Shaykh Haitham al-Haddad. An academic paper on arXiv lists him among scholars who hold bitcoin impermissible, citing its lack of backing and central authority.
For, or conditionally for
- Mufti Muhammad Abu-Bakar, Blossom Finance (5 April 2017). His Shariah analysis concludes that "yes, bitcoin (and most cryptocurrency) is halal", and that bitcoin "qualifies as Islamic money, except where banned by local government". He states the answer is "not intended to be final or legally binding".
- Securities Commission Malaysia, Shariah Advisory Council (announced 7 July 2020). It resolved in principle that "it is permissible to invest and trade in digital currencies and tokens on registered digital asset exchanges". The details were to follow once the resolution was finalised. It applies only within the Commission's jurisdiction.
Mixed
- Mufti Faraz Adam (paper summarised in January 2018). He found that bitcoin "does seem to be Māl with Taqawwum (legal value)" but "does not possess Thamaniyyah (currency attributes)". He judged it not ideal as a long-term holding and said Islamic finance should avoid using it in exchange "unless there is a specific need" until a regulated, transparent framework exists (National Law Review summary). The paper itself describes his view as an opinion, not a fatwa.
Why scholars disagree: four tests
1. Is it maal (property)?
Shariah treats an asset as property only if it can be owned, held and has recognised value. Abu-Bakar and Faraz Adam say bitcoin meets this test. The Karachi fatwa says crypto does not. Everything that follows depends on this question.
2. Riba (interest)
Sending a coin from one wallet to another does not involve paying or receiving interest. The questions start with products built on top of crypto, such as fixed-yield accounts, crypto loans and margin funding. These can reintroduce riba in the same way a conventional interest-bearing deposit does. The International Islamic Fiqh Academy's Resolution 63 (1/7) of May 1992 deals with shares, not crypto. It rules that buying a share with a broker's interest-bearing loan is "not permissible" because it involves riba.
3. Gharar (excessive uncertainty)
Egypt's ruling, Diyanet's ruling and the Indonesian council's ruling all cite price uncertainty. Scholars who permit crypto generally accept that holding a volatile asset is different from entering a contract whose terms are unclear.
4. Maysir (gambling)
The Indonesian ruling names gambling as a reason. Resolution 63 also rules that buying and selling an index is not permissible because it is "pure gambling" and "the sale of something fictitious".
Derivatives, leverage and short selling
The rulings above do not address crypto derivatives directly. The closest authoritative text is older: IIFA Resolution 63 (1/7), adopted 9–14 May 1992:
- Options are not permissible, because "the object of the contract is neither a sum of money nor a utility or a financial right which may be waived". Trading them is also not permissible.
- Future-delivery contracts that "may be terminated by an opposite contract" without actual delivery are "essentially not permissible by Shariah". The resolution does not use the word "futures", and extending it to cash-settled crypto derivatives is a matter of interpretation.
- Selling a share you do not own, with the broker lending it, is not permissible, because it falls under selling what you do not possess.
Leveraged and short positions are where the most authoritative texts lean most clearly against permissibility, even among scholars who accept spot holdings.
Which ruling's reasoning applies to your holding?
Answer the article's screening questions about a specific crypto asset or product to see which rulings' reasoning it runs into.
Do you accept that the asset is maal (property that can be owned, held and has recognised value)?
- Yes, I follow scholars who treat it as property → next question
- No, I follow the Karachi fatwa's reasoning → The analysis stops at the property test
What is the contract form: spot ownership with immediate settlement, or an option, a contract closed out without delivery, or a short sale?
- Spot ownership with immediate settlement → next question
- An option, a contract closed out without delivery, or a short sale → Contract form is where the texts lean most clearly against
Does the product pay or charge a predetermined return, such as fixed yield, lending interest or margin funding?
Does the token have a clear underlying asset and a proven benefit?
Is the token's issuance or revenue tied to prohibited activity?
The Darul Uloom Karachi fatwa of 10 June 2026 holds that cryptocurrency, including USDT, is not maal under Sharia and that buying goods with it is impermissible. On that reasoning, the questions about trading methods never start.
IIFA Resolution 63 (1/7) of May 1992 rules that options, future-delivery contracts closed out by an opposite contract without delivery, and selling a share you do not own are not permissible. It does not mention crypto: applying it to cash-settled crypto derivatives is the article's inference.
Moving a coin between wallets involves no interest, but fixed-yield accounts, crypto loans and margin funding can reintroduce riba the way an interest-bearing deposit does. Resolution 63 rules that buying a share with a broker's interest-bearing loan is not permissible.
The Indonesian council's 2021 fatwa ruled that using crypto as currency is haram and that trading it as a commodity is not valid, except for crypto with a clear underlying asset and a proven benefit. Check whether your own country's Shariah or regulatory body has ruled.
Malaysia's Shariah Advisory Council requires that a token's proceeds, rights and benefits be Shariah-compliant. A token tied to prohibited activity fails that condition even where trading is otherwise permitted.
Malaysia's 2020 resolution permits investing and trading on registered digital asset exchanges within its jurisdiction, while the Karachi fatwa of 2026, Egypt's mufti and Diyanet rule against. For a personal ruling, ask a qualified scholar who knows the specific product.
This walks through the article's screening questions only. It is not a fatwa or financial advice, does not check any specific coin or platform, and cannot tell you whose ruling to follow.
A screening checklist built from the rulings above
This checklist is not a fatwa. It turns the reasoning used by the bodies above into questions you can ask about a specific asset or product:
- Property. Do you accept that the asset is maal? On the Karachi fatwa's reasoning, the analysis stops here.
- Jurisdiction. Does your country's Shariah or regulatory body have a ruling? Malaysia's applies to registered exchanges in Malaysia. Indonesia's council rules out currency use and commodity trading.
- Interest. Does the product pay or charge a predetermined return, such as fixed yield, lending interest or margin funding?
- Underlying. Is there a clear underlying asset and a proven benefit? This is the Indonesian exception.
- Contract form. Is it spot ownership with immediate settlement, or an option, a contract closed out without delivery, or a short sale (see Resolution 63)?
- Use of proceeds. Is the token's issuance or revenue tied to prohibited activity? Malaysia's council requires that a token's proceeds, rights and benefits be Shariah-compliant.
Zakat on crypto holdings
Among scholars who treat crypto as wealth, zakat applies. The Zakat Foundation of America states that "cryptocurrencies are Zakat-eligible wealth". Zakat becomes due when holdings stay at or above the nisab for a full lunar year (hawl), at a rate of 2.5%. The Foundation sets the nisab at the current value of 85 grams of gold. Some zakat bodies use a silver-based nisab instead, which is lower. The nisab moves with the gold or silver price, so value it on the day zakat falls due.
Lower-ambiguity alternatives
If the lack of consensus rules crypto out for you, the alternatives usually discussed in Islamic finance include:
- Sukuk. IIFA Resolution 74 (5/8) of June 1993 sets out Shariah applications for the Islamic market, including sukuk.
- Shariah-screened equities. Resolution 63 permits shares in companies whose main activity is lawful.
- Gold bought for immediate delivery.
Bottom line
As of October 2026, the most recent authoritative ruling, Karachi's in June 2026, says crypto is not wealth. Malaysia's 2020 resolution permits trading on registered exchanges. Indonesia's 2021 fatwa forbids both currency use and commodity trading except for asset-backed tokens. Individual scholars range from "halal" (Abu-Bakar) to "property but not currency" (Faraz Adam) to impermissible (Egypt, Diyanet). Pakistan's planned Shariah Advisory Board may yet add a regulator-backed view. For a personal ruling, ask a qualified scholar who knows the specific product. This is not religious, financial or investment advice.